How this West African country is taking a watch to the success Uganda has correct destroyed to clear up its electrical energy disaster
THE LAST WORD | Andrew M. Mwenda | I am in Accra, Ghana, and this country is attempting to reform its energy sector. To be explicit, they are shopping for an investor to comprehend over their electrical energy distribution community. They must destroy it into five areas and concession it out. The purpose right here is to end a ways from the advent of a monopoly. Ensuing from this truth, each and every save of residing will be given a determined electrical energy distribution concessionaire. And wager which example they are taking a watch at? Umeme, the corporate that Uganda correct destroyed. It’s fantastic how oblivious to our contain successes our govt is. However let me first provide a background.
Ghana has a excessive economic command, which has led them to evaluate of privatizing the distribution community. The country went on a borrowing spree between 2016 and 2022 and went bankrupt in 2022. It declared a moratorium on its public debt, i.e., that it became unable to pay its collectors. Anybody who held govt bonds became forced to easily bag a 55% haircut. Whereas you occur to held a bond price Shs 10 billion (the forex right here typically known as cedi), the govt.promised to pay abet Shs 4.5 billion completely. To acquire issues worse for its collectors, the govt.iced up all funds—for a while.
The catastrophe didn’t slay there. To pay for its quite a lot of public expenditure tasks, the govt.printed money. This caused an inflationary spiral, which peaked at 55% that yr. In accordance with our example above, the price of your final and unpaid Shs 4.5 billion fell (in shopping power terms) to Shs 2.2 billion. The price of the local forex fell from 9 cedis to the buck to 17. International bondholders due to this truth suffered badly. Whereas you occur to bought paid in cedis and exchanged it for greenbacks, you misplaced extra than half of the price.
The completely those that didn’t lose are bilateral and multilateral collectors, i.e., governments and multinational monetary institutions. Ghana went abet into an IMF program with stringent demands for fiscal prudence. Its leg-room for borrowing became severely restricted by the IMF, which now began to give it hobby-free loans to repay about a of its collectors. For traditional Ghanaians, their life’s savings beget been practically wiped out by a stroke of a pen. It is this madden that contributed to a mighty diploma to the defeat of the NPP presidential candidate by John Mahama, the contemporary president.
The Mahama govt due to this truth inherited a truly immoral economic system. The govt. is attempting to reform itself to unravel this disaster. One of many supreme fiscal considerations in Ghana is electrical energy subsidies. These definitely price the taxpayer US$ 2.1 billion per yr. This figure became recorded in January when the contemporary president became sworn in. Provided that Ghana has since loved an appreciating forex (the cedi has liked from 17 cedis to the buck to 11 nowadays), the buck price of those subsidies must beget come down.
Nonetheless, using the January numbers, it system that Ghana would maybe also, every yr, manage to pay for to assemble one Karuma Dam (with an keep in ability of 600MW) and Isimba Dam (with an keep in ability of 180MW) plus their transmission traces from savings on the electrical energy subsidies alone. How did this unhappy country with a GDP of $76 billion on the time (and attributable to of forex appreciation it has now long gone to $88 billion) acquire to such absurdity? It is very conceivable that it is miles attributable to of democratic politics.
Ghanaian leaders must compete for votes to return to predicament of job. Presidential elections right here are very cease, on the overall to a margin of 51:49 p.c. Every vote counts attributable to the adaptation between presidential candidates, correct admire in neighboring Kenya, is on the overall round 200,000 votes. Presidential candidates due to this truth acquire many spending guarantees that the country can no longer manage to pay for. This is coupled with reluctance to impose contemporary taxes, incentives to comprehend away inclined ones, and reluctance to scrupulously accumulate taxes (lest they alienate voters). It is this toxic mixture that ends in fiscal catastrophe.
This brings us abet to Uganda. President Yoweri Museveni implemented many of basically the most controversial reforms sooner than our country entered the tight grip of electoral opponents. As democratic opponents has deepened, so has grown the reluctance for excessive reform. This is how Umeme took predicament in the early 2000s. The govt. eradicated electrical energy subsidies and ensured that the country had a place-reflective tariff. Uganda is the completely country in Africa where the tariff covers both the price of funding and operational prices and makes a super income on the tip.
Ghana has learn the story of how Umeme transformed a moribund and loss-making distribution community with 38% technical and business losses into an efficient and worthwhile outfit. Take notice of that in 2001, when the Ugandan govt invited companies to exact hobby in our electrical energy distribution community, six companies replied. When they came to make due diligence, all of them walked away with out the courtesy of informing the govt.of their disinterest—moreover one company, CDC, a British govt parastatal.
I beget written this story many cases, so I might no longer repeat myself right here. So unattractive became Uganda’s electrical energy distribution replace that the first patrons turned out to be two govt parastatals—CDC and Eskom of South Africa—who fashioned a consortium to spread the pain. In 2008, Umeme tried to borrow money, and no monetary institution on the planet became willing to lend to them. The completely loans they would maybe even honest elevate beget been from IFC and beget been assured by the World Bank. (READ Darkish days ahead for Uganda)
Yet by 2013, when Umeme listed on the stock market, its shares beget been oversubscribed by 157%. When they did the 2d itemizing, they beget been oversubscribed by 400%. The supreme equity companies on the planet, with a blended monetary chest of $1.5 trillion price of funding funds below management, beget been bidding to amass shares in Umeme. This meant that if Uganda wished to invest a billion greenbacks in the distribution community, it wouldn’t beget had to borrow. Umeme would correct trudge on the stock market and elevate equity.
That is the intangible price that the govt.of Uganda destroyed on a whim. In point of fact, Ghana wouldn’t beget long gone browsing on the market if Umeme quiet existed. The main resolution makers right here beget been ready to skim to Uganda to position a matter to Umeme to return blueprint up store in Ghana. They are now shopping for the inclined homeowners of Umeme to return make the identical magic on this country. With the corporate destroyed, most of its intangible property, comparable to institutional cohesion and memory, concentrated skills, and organizational kinds, are long gone. Discuss of shooting ourselves in the toes the entire time.
****
amwenda@ugindependent.co.ug
